-
Abstracts and Biographical
Notes
-
Indigenous Talking Circles
-
Workshops
Abstracts and Biographical
Notes
Steven Bennetts and Stephen Walker
Burrup rock art, the native title process and WA’s failed heritage
protection regime
Woodside and the Government have decided to construct the Pluto
Liquid Natural Gas plant in the middle of the world’s oldest and largest
rock art gallery, which is also a site of major significance to local
Aboriginal people. The cultural advocacy group Friends of Australian
Rock Art (FARA) was established in 2006 with the principal objective of
challenging plans by the State Government and Woodside for continuing
destruction of Aboriginal cultural heritage on the Burrup Peninsula
which has gone on since the 1970s.
In this presentation, FARA barrister Stephen Walker and
anthropologist Stephen Bennetts will critique the current dysfunctional
WA Aboriginal heritage protection regime, and suggest how local NTRBs
and FARA may be able to mount a successful legal challenge to the
current arrangements. They will also explain how the local native title
and BMIEA agreement processes have had the convenient esffect for the
company and State Government of dividing the local Aboriginal community,
marginalizing the local NTRB from involvement in the issue, and thus
weakening Aboriginal opposition to the project. The speakers will
describe FARA’s attempts to transcend differences between rival native
title claimant groups and build a unified front against the continued
destruction of Aboriginal heritage on the Burrup.
Stephen Walker is a Perth barrister who represented native
title claimants in the Wongatha native title claim in the GLC region,
and also acts for Friends of Australian Rock Art.
Stephen Bennetts has worked as a staff and consultant
anthropologist on native title NTLRA and heritage protection issues for
various Aboriginal organisations in the NT and WA since 1994. He was
co-editor of the Indigenous Law Bulletin and editor of the Australian
Indigenous Law Reporter from 1998-2000, and was a founding member of
Friends of Australian Rock Art in 2006. He is completing a PhD in
Anthropology at the University of WA.
Wayne Bergmann
Wayne Bergmann is Executive Director of the
Kimberley Land Council (KLC), one of Australia’s leading organisations
dealing with Aboriginal land rights and resource development issues.
Negotiations for the development of multi-billion dollar gas reserves
off the Kimberley coastline put the region and its people at the
pinnacle of the resources boom. As the peak body representing Indigenous
people in the region, the KLC and Mr. Bergmann are playing a crucial
role in determining how development will proceed. In between mining
giants, state and federal governments and environment groups, the KLC is
fighting to ensure any development delivers long-term opportunities and
benefits for Indigenous communities, while at the same time respecting
and protecting cultural and environmental values.
Mr. Bergmann has Nykina, Nyul Nyul, Greek and Sri
Lankan ancestry, and grew up near Derby in the Kimberley region of
Australia. He has a strong community background and worked in the region
as a qualified boilermaker and contractor, and as Executive Director of
the Kimberley Aboriginal Law and Culture Centre, before studying formal
law in Perth. He worked in Chambers and private practice in Perth,
before returning to the Kimberley to take up the position with the KLC.
Mr Bergmann has been Executive Director of the KLC since 2001. During
that time, the KLC has assisted Aboriginal Traditional Owners gain
native title determinations covering more than 210,000 square kilometers
( over 45 per cent) of Kimberley country. Mr Bergmann has also overseen
the successful negotiation of a number of significant agreements between
resource developers and Traditional Owners across the Kimberley. This
includes major agreements with one of the world’s largest diamond
producers, Argyle Diamond Mines, Tanami Gold and Aztec
Resources. Central to each of these agreements has been securing real
and ongoing benefits to Indigenous people, in terms of employment and
business opportunities, community development, land, and investment in
the future.
Anthony Beven and Lisa Donnelly
New directions for the Registrar of Aboriginal and Torres Strait
Islander Corporations
This paper sets out the new directions for the Office of the
Registrar of Indigenous Corporations (ORIC). ORIC has reshaped its
priorities to lift the performance and capacity of Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander corporations. This includes increasing the number of
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander organisations registered under the
Corporations Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander (CATSI) Act,
increasing the level of compliance among corporations and reviewing how
ORIC measures compliance. ORIC also aims to reduce compliance costs for
corporations by, among other things, developing a simplified rule book.
A guide to this shorter rule book has been developed especially for
prescribed bodies corporate and will be launched at the Native Title
Conference 2008. This guide will significantly contribute to the
capacity of PBCs to transition to the new CATSI Act, supported by ORIC’s
expanded corporate governance training program.
Anthony Beven was appointed Registrar of Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander Corporations (now known as the Registrar of Indigenous
Corporations) on 1 October 2007. He was previously Regional Commissioner
for the Australian Securities and Investments Commission in South
Australia and before that in the Northern Territory. Anthony was a
national advisor in Consumer Protection, especially on issues facing
Indigenous and regional consumers. He has also been the Registrar of
Companies in Papua New Guinea and founding Chairman of the Papua New
Guinea Securities Commission as well the Papua New Guinea Accounting
Standards Board.
Lisa Donnelly is Acting Director of the CATSI Communications
section at the ORIC. She has been Assistant Director since joining the
organisation in 2006. With a background in graphic design, Lisa has been
instrumental in revitalising the look and feel of publications and
training materials for ORIC.
Simon Blackshield
Sections 66B and 251B of the Native Title Act
1993
A discussion of the law of authorisation for
native title claims, including the requirement for claims to be
authorised by properly-constituted claim groups, the question of whether
there will be a relevant ’traditional‘ process for authorising claims,
and the making of applications to change applicants on claims.
Simon Blackshield is a lawyer who has been
practising in the native title area since 1994, on the east and west
coasts. While employed by the NSW Aboriginal Land Council in the
mid-90s, he conducted the Dunghutti Crescent Head claim, which was the
first successful native title claim on mainland Australia, producing the
first determination of native title under the NTA. He currently works as
In-house Counsel at the South West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council, and
also has his own practice which focuses on NSW and Queensland.
Jane Blackwood and Johnny Hopiga
The survival of land and sea management units
The availability of funding resources now available
for Indigenous land management has led to the growth in land and sea
units across the country. There are some key issues that need to be
addressed if these units are to survive and be sustainable into the
future.
Jane Blackwood is qualified in tropical
ecology, GIS, community development, rural extension and adult
education. Jane has been working across different sectors in Northern
Australia since1985 including mining, agricultural production, natural
resource management, conservation, adult education and ranger programs.
She arrived in the Kimberley in 2004 to work with fire management and
then moved into the Land and Sea Management Unit at the Kimberley Land
Council in 2006.
Johnny Hopiga is a Karajarri man and Head
Ranger of the Karajarri Rangers. He has an outstation on country and
teaches kids Karajarri law. Johnny is also a committee member of the
Karajarri Traditional Lands Association.
Bob Blair and Leah Armstrong
Creating Indigenous wealth and economic development through industry
partnerships
Indigenous Business Australia works closely with industry experts and
Indigenous investors, with the aim to create an asset base and build
wealth for Indigenous Australians. This paper will present investment
case studies and will demonstrate how the suite of IBA’s programs work
together with local Indigenous communities and industry partners to
create commercial joint ventures that lead to spin off opportunities for
Indigenous employment and small business development. Indigenous
Australians require an asset base to participate in and benefit from the
mainstream economy, and Indigenous Business Australia has acquired
considerable expertise in assisting Indigenous communities to
participate in joint venture arrangements. Where possible, further
business development and mentoring can be achieved by supporting
Indigenous contractors to develop the necessary skills to take advantage
of opportunities created by commercial activities. Employment and
training strategies can then be implemented to build the capacity of
local communities to respond to the labour requirements generated. This
paper demonstrates that by creating wealth by building the asset base of
Indigenous Australians through investment partnerships, can also lead to
significant flow on effects in economic participation through employment
and small business development.
Bob Blair has been an IBA Board member
since 3 July 1998. He has an extensive business background as the
administrator of the Dreamtime Cultural Centre, Rockhampton,
North Queensland. Mr Blair also has Indigenous training experience,
having been a senior training officer with the Central Queensland
Aboriginal Corporation for Training Resources. In 2001, Mr Blair was
awarded the Centenary Medal for service to the community through
cultural awareness activities.
Leah Armstrong is a foundation member and the Executive
Director of the NSW based Yarnteen Ltd which is a not for profit
Indigenous organisation. She has built Yarnteen into a robust enterprise
with a creative and entrepreneurial spirit that inspires its employees
and makes a difference in the Indigenous community. Other directorships
and committee appointments include: Indigenous Business Australia,
Chair of the Aboriginal Business Roundtable NSW, member of the Board of
Vocational Education and Training NSW and Non Member Director NTS Corp
NSW.
Stuart Bradfield, Sally McMartin, Ted Hart, Peter
Michael, Karri-Anne Kearing & James Khan
Moorditj Booja: A Community Partnership Agreement
Moorditj Booja: A Community Partnership Agreement’ was signed off by
the Gnaala Karla Booja people, SWALSC, Newmont and Anglo-Gold Ashanti in
August 2006. The agreement commits the Boddington Gold Mine (BGM)
(located 130 km south east of Perth) to employ at least 100 Aboriginal
people, and provides for a suite of benefits to the local GKB people,
including education, training, and business development. As BGM gears up
to full production in early 2009, implementation of this significant
agreement gathers pace. This session will explore a range of complex
issues experienced by partners to the agreement, with open and frank
perspectives offered by representatives from all the key parties: the
Tradition Owner Liaison Committee, SWALSC, and Newmont.
Dr Stuart Bradfield is the Manger, Regional Economic
Partnerships, at the South West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council. Prior
to that he worked for the WA Office of Native Title, and as a Visiting
Research Fellow in the Native Title Research Unit at AIATSIS. His main
area of interest is treaty and agreement making between Indigenous and
other peoples, and he has published articles and book chapters on
treaty, agreement making, genocide, native title and Aboriginal affairs
policy and politics.
Ted Hart has been Chairperson of the South West Aboriginal
Land and Sea Council (SWALSC) since December 2003 being re-elected
following the May 2005 elections. He was born in Bunbury and educated at
Darkan and Governor Stirling Senior High School. Ted has had a long
standing involvement with Aboriginal and mainstream employment. This has
included a position as Chair with the Aboriginal Legal Service in 1983,
Sports Officer with the Aboriginal Advancement Council, Welfare Officer
with the Civil Rehabilitation Council and Youth Development Officer at
the Tharrawal Aboriginal Corporation. For the last 10 years Ted has been
a self-employed Aboriginal Heritage Consultant.
Karri-Anne Kearing is part of the
Traditional owner Liaison Committee established under the CPA.
James Khan is part of the Traditional owner
Liaison Committee established under the CPA.
Sally McMartin is the Senior Manager External Affairs for
Newmont Australia. Sally has been with the company approximately five
years and this is her first posting in the mining industry. Under the
banner of External Affairs Sally's key areas of responsibly are
Community Relations, Indigenous Affairs, Government Relations. In her
time with Newmont she has assisted to develop and drive the company's
Indigenous training and employment strategies nationally and at a site
level. Sally sees that the success of Newmont's programs has been the
development of strong partnership arrangements with Land Councils,
Government and the local communities.
Prior to working in Newmont Sally worked for ATSIC in Canberra as the
senior manager for Strategic Human Resources and before that was a
private consultant. Many of her clients in her consultancy practice were
from the community and not for profit sector. She undertook such work
as program reviews and evaluations, strategic planning, training and
development
Peter Michael is part of the Traditional
owner Liaison Committee established under the CPA.
Tom Calma
Sustainable options for Australia’s new national Indigenous
representative body
In late 2007, the Aboriginal and Torres Strait
Islander Social Justice Commissioner commissioned research on options
for a new national representative body for Indigenous peoples. The
research and consultation undertaken for this paper will examine:
What lessons can be learnt from mechanisms for representing Aboriginal
and Torres Strait Islander peoples at the national level that have
previously existed?
What options are there for ensuring that a national Indigenous
representative body is sustainable?
What lessons can be learned from mechanisms for representing
Indigenous peoples that have been established in other countries? The
paper that will be presented will discuss these three questions and seek
to identify culturally appropriate and sustainable options for the new
national Indigenous representative body to be established by the Federal
Government. The paper seeks to inform and underpin a broader national
discussion on the best possible Indigenous representative body for
Australia.
Human rights and Indigenous engagement with rapidly evolving
climate change policy
This paper considers Indigenous engagement in climate change policy,
and adaptation and mitigation strategy, at the international and
national level from a human rights perspective. It looks at:
- outcomes from the Seventh Session of the United Nations Permanent
Forum on Indigenous Issues and the International Expert Group meeting
on Indigenous Peoples and Climate Change;
- the Garnaut Climate Change Review; and
- the capacity of the native title system to deal with climate
change.
Tom Calma is an Aboriginal elder from the
Kungarakan tribal group and the Iwaidja tribal group whose traditional
lands are south west of Darwin and on the Coburg Peninsula in the
Northern Territory. He has been involved in Indigenous affairs at a
local, community, state, national and international level and has worked
in the public sector for over 30 years. Until his appointment on 12 July
2004 as Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice
Commissioner, for an appointment of five years and national Race
Discrimination Commissioner by annual appointment, Mr Calma managed the
Community Development and Education Branch at Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander Services where he worked with remote Indigenous
communities to implement community-based and driven empowerment and
participation programs. In 2003, he was Senior Adviser of Indigenous
Affairs to the Minister of Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous
Affairs and from 1995 to 2002 he was a senior diplomat in India and
Vietnam. Commissioner Calma is also a White Ribbon Day Ambassador, the
International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women, held on
25 November each year. Mr Calma has been an Ambassador since 2005.
Commissioner Calma is also a National Patron of Wakakirri National Story
Festival.
David Campbell, Paul Burgess, Stephen Garnett and John Wakerman
An economic estimate of the probable savings in health costs from
participation in Indigenous Cultural Natural Resource Management (ICNRM)
At the request of traditional owners a recent study was undertaken
in, central Arnhem Land, in collaboration with a trans-disciplinary team
of medical, ecological and social researchers to test the nexus between
healthy people and healthy country. The study results showed a
significant inverse association between risk indicators for diabetes and
cardiovascular disease and the level of participation in Indigenous
cultural natural resource management, or ICNRM. That is, it was observed
that those who had a higher ICNRM score showed a lower indicative risk.
In this paper we report on the probable cost savings in primary health
care for diabetes, renal disease, hypertension, cardiovascular disease
and combinations of these chronic diseases on the assumption that the
data shows a causative relationship. We show the estimated savings in
primary health care are substantial. These results provide support, in
addition to environmental benefits, for facilitating ICNRM. Inclusion of
a broader range of health benefits, including possible savings in
secondary health care and the benefits of a healthier community would
further enhance the estimated social benefits.
David Campbell has held the position of
senior research economist at the Centre for Remote Health, Alice
Springs, since February 2007. This position is jointly funded by the
Centre and Desert Knowledge CRC, and includes teaching the graduate
course in health economics. He previously worked as a natural resource
economist with the Australian Bureau of Agriculture and Resource
Economics, prior to setting up his own consultancy in 1997, where he
contracted to Aboriginal organisations, state and commonwealth
government departments and international bodies; and lectured at the
Crawford School of Economics and Government, Australian National
University. His research focus is on the economies obtainable through
the joint supply of environmental and health benefits generated through
the involvement of Aboriginal people in traditional land management
practices. The results of this work are at variance to the possible
efficiencies obtained through the aggregation of Aboriginal outstations
into larger communities.
Trevor Close
The Githabul PBC
Trevor Close is an Indigenous commercial
lawyer currently working in the resources industry. Mr Close has been
assisting Traditional Owners capitalise upon their native title assets
through building commercial partnerships with Investment Banks such as
Cube Finance, Lehman Bros and Leighton Contractors. Mr Close was the
principal claimant for the Githabul Tribal Nation who recently won the
largest settlement for native title on the east coast of Australia. The
Githabul people now have joint management with the NSW government over
ten National Parks and five state forests as well some Travelling Stock
Routes.
Dennis Eggington
Dennis Eggington has been Chief Executive
Officer at Aboriginal Legal Service Western Australia (ALSWA) since
1995. He came to the position with a wealth of experience gained through
involvement with a wide range of Aboriginal organisations. Dennis has a
background in education, management and community development. He holds
a Diploma of Teaching and a Bachelor of Applied Science. His
professional experience includes teaching and management roles with the
WA Aboriginal Media Association, the WA Aboriginal Education
Consultative Group, the Curtin University's Centre for Aboriginal
Studies, Derbarl Yerrigan Health Service and the Dumbartung Aboriginal
Corporation. His role is overall management at ALSWA and he represents
ALSWA on a number of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander committees.
Dennis is a Noongar man who maintains strong links with his community
Margarita Escartin
‘Who are you? No-one
asked me!’ - Managing Risk in Agreement Making: A Model for
Authorisation of Indigenous Land Use Agreements
The highway leading to authorisation of Indigenous
Land Use Agreements (ILUAs) is seldom smooth sailing on cruise control.
More often than not there will be a number of pot holes, sharp turns,
flat tyres and steep hills requiring skilled drivers, co-pilots and
trusting passengers to reach the final destination. Issues are always
complex and multilayered, involving numbers of stakeholders who may have
conflicting imperatives and needs informing their positioning, often
incompatible time constraints on all parties and usually resourcing
issues.
The process towards a positive outcome, an
authorised and registered ILUA, must be proactively managed and
carefully balanced through a structured framework of engagement with and
by all participants: of project proponents and claim group
representatives or negotiators, of claim group representatives and those
who must authorise the making of agreements ie native title holders of
the ILUA area, of facilitating parties eg land council staff and their
management and of project proponents, their advisers and upper levels of
decision makers.
The risk is always that ILUAs will not be
authorised or they will fail registration testing. It is my experience
that the predominant issues contributing to that risk are: Who are the
native title holders? Have they had an opportunity to participate in
consultation? Have those persons authorised? These risks must be managed
through constant monitoring, and proactive mitigation - ensuring that
consent from native title holders claimants is obtained at all
milestones in the negotiation process. Consent is at the heart of the
authorisation process and it is that consent that forms a component of
the social licence to operate in communities and on country.
It is also my experience that multiparty agreement
on claim appropriate process, comprehensive resourcing, intra-group
mediation where necessary and hands-on management by the native title
holders can produce wonderful results.
This presentation is a Model for Authorisation of
Indigenous Land Use Agreements (Area Agreements) that attempts to
provide a structured roadmap to manage the layers, as well as provide a
basis for compliance with statutory requirements. It is a model that has
been used effectively and with great success in the central Queensland
region, has application for other aspects of authorisation under the
Native Title Act and which may provide sufficient flexibility to develop
claim group specific processes in other areas around Australia.
Margarita Escartin
is a solicitor in the Property and Commercial Services division of
Gadens Lawyers, Brisbane. She previously worked as a legal officer in a
Native Title Representative Body, and enjoyed a particular focus on
agreement making: designing and managing negotiation processes in
consultation with claimants and facilitating negotiations between
claimants and third party interests. Margarita was admitted as a
solicitor in 2000 and has worked predominantly in litigation since that
time. She is originally from Sydney and currently resides in Brisbane
with her family. Margarita continues her work with native title clients
and has also expanded her area of practice to advising and negotiating
on behalf of proponents.
Robert French, Raelene Webb, Gary Hamley and Tony Neal
Strategic use of court procedures to avoid unnecessary litigation
The Federal
Court's presentation will provide the opportunity for a conversation
based upon the wide and varied experiences of a range of panellists who
are familiar with the strategic use of Court procedures to achieve
outcomes and avoid unnecessary litigation. The conversation will
be moderated by the Registrar and the panel will include Justice Robert
French.
This will be
complemented by excerpts from two DVDs recently produced by the Court:
one that focuses upon assisting witnesses,
the other upon reflections of legal practitioners who have conducted
many native title cases. Both showcase experiences and practice relevant
to all cases but are particularly relevant to an early or limited
evidence hearing.
Justice Robert French is a Judge of the
Federal Court of Australia. He is a graduate of the University of
Western Australia in science and law. He was admitted in 1972 and
practised as a barrister and solicitor in Western Australia until 1983
when he went to the Independent Bar. He was appointed to the Federal
Court in 1986. From 1994 to 1998 he was President of the National Native
Title Tribunal. Justice French is an additional member of the Supreme
Court of the Australian Capital Territory and a member of the Supreme
Court of Fiji. He is a member of the Australian Competition Tribunal and
a part-time member of the Australian Law Reform Commission. From 2001 to
January 2005 he was President of the Australian Association of
Constitutional Law.
Gary Hamley
The Native Title Mediation Process:
Insights and Developments
The State of Western Australia is the first
respondent for native title applications filed in this State. The
Office of Native Title represents the State of Western Australia’s
interests during the mediation of native title determination
applications. The State Government prefers negotiation to litigation in
resolving native title applications, whenever possible. Since 2000,
fifteen consent determinations have been achieved through the process of
mediation, usually facilitated by the National Native Title Tribunal.
As a result, the State has accumulated significant experience as a
participant in mediation. Mediation has presented opportunities for the
State to develop consistency in internal processes and improve
relationships with key stakeholders, particularly with Native Title
Representative Bodies. Through the course of negotiations the State has
clarified its position on issues that emerge during mediation and
thereby contributed to achieving consent determinations and enabling
potential future consent determinations. This paper explores whether,
with the increasing experience of all parties, native title mediation in
Western Australia is becoming less challenging. It revisits a number of
innovations introduced by the Office of Native Title, as lead negotiator
for the State in mediation, including techniques used to settle and
advance the State’s position on issues and the terms of consent
determinations. The paper explores factors that have allowed parties to
narrow the issues and some of the continuing challenges.
Gary Hamley has been the Executive Director,
Office of Native Title since 2004. He has over thirty years service in
the Western Australian Public Sector, and extensive experience at the
highest levels of Government, as a Ministerial Chief of Staff and in a
range of portfolio areas including health, labour relations, police and
emergency services. Gary has a strong commitment to partnership
approaches to service delivery and government responsiveness to
community needs. He is also a skilled manager, with a desire to see
that the Office of Native Title is well resourced and operating
efficiently. In his time as Executive Director, Gary has overseen a
major growth in the Office, and has been pivotal in progressing
negotiations for the resolution of eight native title determination
applications and the implementation of two major native title
agreements.
Ted Hart and Glen Kelly
The Bennell decision
In September 2006 the Noongar people celebrated the
recognition of their connection to country by a judge of the Federal
Court. Justice Wilcox found that the Noongar people were a single
community, as they asserted, that had continued to exist, had maintained
their connection to country and acknowledge and observe their laws and
customs, including those that determine rights and interests in land.
The decision was met with disbelief by the State, who immediately
announced their intention to appeal the decision. In April this year a
full bench of the Federal court upheld the appeal by the State and,
although they didn’t make any finding against the Noongar people’s
claim, they sent the matter back to another single judge to be
reconsidered according to a different understanding of how the questions
are to be addressed by the Court. In this session, the chairperson on
the South West Aboriginal Land and Sea council, their Executive Director
and their legal Counsel will share their view of the decision, the
process leading up to the appeal and consider where to now for Noongar
people and their native title claim.
Ted Hart is the Chairperson of the South
West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council (SWALSC) (see full details above).
Glen Kelly is the Chief Executive Officer (CEO)
of the SWALSC. Glen is a Noongar man and brings to SWALSC 14 years of
experience in Indigenous Affairs, much of it in native title and
Indigenous land related issues. Glen has held a number of senior
positions in Indigenous organisations, both as a manger and as an
advocate of Indigenous interests, as well as positions within Government
agencies. Glen sits on a number of high level committees and statutory
authorities at a State and Commonwealth level that relate to Indigenous
land interests. Glen is a keen advocate of Noongar interests, and in his
role as the CEO, seeks to ensure that SWALSC is able to provide an
efficient and effective service to Noongar people and their native title
claims. The CEO is appointed by the Executive Committee and acts in
accordance with the policies determined by that committee. He attends
the Executive Committee meetings and provides regular reports in
reference to the operations of the organisation.
Colleen Hayward
Professor Colleen Hayward is Manager, the
Kulunga Research Network of the Telethon Institute for Child Health
Research and Associate Professor, Curtin University. She has an
extensive policy, negotiation, advocacy and management background in
health, education, training, employment and housing, including the
Aboriginal and Torres Straight Islander Services agency, and was
previously deputy Chief Executive Officer of the Aboriginal Legal
Service of WA. Her expertise covers aboriginal child health, aboriginal
disadvantage, aboriginal research and indigenous health policy. For more
than 20 years she has influenced policies and programs on issues
reflecting the needs of minority groups at State Government, national
and community levels. This year she was recipient of the prestigious
Premier of Western Australia’s Multicultural Ambassador Award for her
commitment to progressing human rights and addressing racism in our
community. Professor Hayward is a senior Noongar woman with family ties
throughout the South-West of Western Australia and has built lasting
partnerships and initiatives between Indigenous and non-Indigenous
Western Australians. She is an inspiring speaker with the ability to
communicate across cultural and other boundaries.
Wilfred Hicks, Robyne Churnside and David Milroy
‘On being a custodian of Aboriginal heritage in WA and having to
deal with the State Government, Woodside and other mining companies’:
Indigenous perspectives on WA’s failed heritage protection regime
Wilfred Hicks is the spokesperson for the
Wong-Goo-Tt-Oo native title group and a custodian of the Burrup
Peninsula. In October 2007, he and Wong-Goo-Tt-Oo law man Tim Douglas
unsuccessfully lodged an application under s 9 and 10 of the Federal
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act with
Minister Malcolm Turnbull to place an injunction on Woodside’s proposed
works on Pluto Site B on the Burrup Peninsula and to establish an
inquiry into the heritage values of the Pluto B lease. The incoming
Minister for Heritage, Peter Garrett subsequently appointed a reporter
in relation to the Wong-Goo-Tt-Oo’s s 10 application.
Robyne Churnside
is a member of the Ngarluma native title group, the Pilbara Native Title
Service Executive Committee, Equal Opportunity Commission Discrimination
Committee and convenor of the Roebourne Strong Women’s Group (and a
possible future member of DIA’s Aboriginal Cultural Materials Committee
which advises the WA Minister for Indigenous Affairs). In November 2007,
she issued the ‘Murujuga Declaration’ at the gates of Woodside’s Pluto
lease, to be published in the April/May issue of the Indigenous Law
Bulletin.
David Milroy is
spokesperson for the Balyku native title group, a custodian with his
sister Sally Morgan of the Abydos/Woodstock area and a successful
Aboriginal playwright and musician. His play ‘Swine River’ attacking the
State-sponsored destruction of WA Aboriginal heritage premiered in Perth
in 2006.
Gerald Hobbler and Rhonda Brim
Up Barron Gorge without a Paddle
The Djabugay from Kuranda in north Queensland had
the first native title consent determination over a national park in
Australia, yet they are struggling to benefit from the ILUA which was
associated with the determination. This presentation will outline some
of the difficulties they have encountered and their efforts to rebuild
their PBC and arrive at a Plan of Management of the Barron Gorge
National Park which accurately reflects their original aspirations for
joint management in Queensland.
Gerald Hobbler is the newly elected
Chairperson of the Djabugay Native Title Aboriginal Corporation and
works at the Kuranda College.
Rhonda Brim is a member of the Djabugay
Governing Committee and has a significant commitment to Djabugay
cultural projects including weaving.
Vance Hughston
What is required for connection
Vance Hughston SC
graduated from the
University of Sydney in 1976 with BA and LLB degrees. He was
subsequently awarded an LLM degree in 1987. He came to the New South
Wales Bar in 1982 and took silk in 2001. From very early on at the Bar,
Vance Hughston SC’s practice included elements of appearance and advice
work in Aboriginal land claims. Since 1994, Mr Hughston SC has been
involved on an almost continuous basis in advising on and in appearing
at the hearing of native title claims in New South Wales, Queensland,
Victoria, Western Australia and the Northern Territory at both trial and
appellate level.
In Western Australia Mr
Hughston SC appeared for the State in the Wongatha, Neowarra
and Nganawangka claims. The Nganawangka claim was settled
after a lengthy hearing and an equally lengthy mediation before the
National Native Title Tribunal. Mr Hughston SC appeared for the
successful applicants in Bennell v Western Australia (2006) 153
FCR 120 and appeared for them at the hearing of the State and other
respondents’ appeals before the Full Federal Court in April 2007. He is
currently appearing for the Garawa Ganggalida People in proceedings in
Queensland.
In the Northern Territory
Mr Hughston SC has appeared for Government interests in a number of
cases before the Federal Court involving issues of administrative law
and the interpretation of various provisions of the NTA. He has also
appeared for Aboriginal groups in administrative law proceedings in the
Federal Court. He appeared for the Northern Territory in the Risk
and Blue Mud Bay native title claims, both at first instance and
on appeal. Mr Hughston SC appeared for the Commonwealth in the Yulara
compensation claim before Sackville J and on the hearing of the appeal.
He has successfully prosecuted miners and pastoralists in the Northern
Territory for damaging or desecrating Aboriginal sites.
George Irving
The Martu Test Case – exclusive Possession and Religious Freedom –v-
the Expedited Procedure
In March 2006 the Western Australian Department of
Industry and Resources issued a number of expedited procedure notices,
“as test cases”, to have the National Native Title Tribunal determine
whether the expedited procedure applies to the grant of exploration
licences in the area where the Martu People have determined native title
rights to possess, occupy, use and enjoy the land and waters to the
exclusion of all others. In January 2008, following two days of
cross-examination of witnesses for the government and grantee parties,
the State decided to withdraw the expedited procedure notices. This left
unexamined the rights, asserted by the Martu People:
- To either take the exploration licences for them selves or to
receive 90% of all royalties in respect of the land the subject of the
tenements, pursuant to the WA Mining Act or, alternatively, to
receive compensation prior to the grant of exploration licences;
- To protect their sacred sites and areas of significance, in
accordance with their distinctive laws and customs, rather than in
accordance with the WA Aboriginal Heritage Act; and,
- To carry out their religious observances free of any interference
by the Commonwealth, pursuant to s. 116 of the Commonwealth
Constitution.
This paper examines the factual and legal
foundations for the assertion of such rights by exclusive possession
native title holders.
George Irving graduated from the Melbourne
University Law School in 1987 and has extensive experience in native
title, mining and administrative law. Prior to resuming his practice as
a barrister, in 2001, he was the Principal Legal Officer of the
Kimberley Land Council, where he worked for 8 years. He was instructing
solicitor in the Mirriuwung and Gajjerong appeals, and has appeared as
counsel in numerous native title matters, including the Karajarri,
Rubibi and Bardi and Jawi trials, and the Central West Goldfields
preservation of evidence hearings. He also has extensive experience in
negotiating native title and heritage agreements and in mediating
intra-Indigenous disputes. Recently he successfully defended an appeal
by the State against the dismissal of a fisheries prosecution on native
title grounds; and authored the report on the Inquiry into the IBA Joint
Venture Businesses and the problems associated with alcohol abuse in
Fitzroy Crossing. His previous published works include: "Reclaiming
the Heart land"-a commentary on the issues, evidence and findings in
Rubibi Community and Anorv The State of Western Australia and Ors
[2001] FCA 607, in the Indigenous Law Bulletin, Vol5, Issue 18,
at p 19; and, "Prescribed Bodies Corporate - the Statutory
Displacement of the Right to Manage Native Title"; in Native Title
in the New Millennium, Bryan Keon-Cohen Editor, Aboriginal Studies
Press, 2001. He is currently the president of the WA Society of Labor
Lawyers and Chairman of Central Desert Native Title Services.
Kirstin Isaacs
Negotiating agreements – The role, benefits and experience of
negotiation teams
The use of negotiation teams in the negotiation of
native title agreements increases the likelihood of sustainable
agreements relevant to, and addressing the priorities of, the particular
Traditional Owner group.
The use of negotiation teams to represent native
title groups raises a number of considerations:
-
Roles and responsibilities of the team
-
Resourcing the team
-
Engagement with the broader native title group
-
The negotiation team’s role in implementing the agreement
The presentation will explore each of these
considerations including the rationale for each and provide people’s
experiences of negotiations.
Roles and responsibilities of the team:
Identifying clearly the role and responsibility of the team and the
individual team members is critical to the overall success of the team.
Identifying the best process to use to identify team composition and to
establish the roles and responsibilities requires knowledge of the
particular group.
Resourcing the team: The resourcing required
will vary depending upon the expertise of the negotiation team.
Resourcing requires the provision of assistance to ensure that the team
can meet its group and individual roles and responsibilities. It
includes provision of expert advice, training in team negotiations,
travel allowances and funding to perform specific duties.
Engagement with the broader native title group:
Native title agreements involve the whole group’s native title and
engagement with the broader group can be critical to the negotiation
process. Group engagement may utilise a number of strategies, the
strategies will depend upon the particular needs of each group.
The negotiation team’s role in implementing the
agreement: The transition from a negotiation to agreement
implementation will require transference of skills and knowledge from
the negotiation team to those implementing the agreement. Strategies
and experience of the transition are explored.
Kirstin Isaacs has worked with a number of
negotiation teams and designed strategies for community engagement in a
broad range of areas. Her experience in the negotiation of native title
agreements spans ten years and includes working for native title
representative bodies as a legal adviser and as a senior negotiator for
a state government. Kirstin’s experience in the design of community
engagement strategies commenced with a position as a community legal
education worker, was furthered during her employment with the social
impact assessment unit in the Queensland government and consolidated in
her work in native title.
Tina Jowett
Recent developments in connection thresholds
Tina Jowett
graduated from the University of New South Wales with a BA (Hons) in
1991 and a LLB in 1994. She came to the New South Wales Bar in February
2003. From 1993 to 1995 she worked part-time at the Indigenous Law
Centre at UNSW as the Co-ordinator of the Mabo Native Title Project.
At the Indigenous Law Centre she was part of a team who prepared a cross
cultural training video from a grant from the Council for
Reconciliation. The video is still shown to Federal Court judges and
practitioners.
In 1995, Tina Jowett was
employed as the Associate to her Honour Justice Jane Mathews, who at
that time was President of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, Deputy
President of the National Native Title Tribunal and a Judge of the
Federal Court. From 1996-2002 Tina Jowett practiced as a solicitor at
the New South Wales Crown Solicitor’s Office including the Native Title
and Constitutional Law Practice Group. As a barrister she has been
briefed to advise and appear in a number of native title matters for
applicants and respondents.
Most recently, Tina Jowett
appeared with Vance Hughston SC for the successful applicants in
Bennell v
Western Australia
(2006) 153 FCR 120 and appeared for them at the hearing of the State and
other respondents’ appeals before the Full Federal Court in April 2007.
She is currently appearing for the Turrbal people in proceedings in
Queensland. Tina Jowett also appears and advises in matters under the
Aboriginal Land
Rights Act 19983
(NSW) in the Land and
Environment Court (NSW).
Marcia Langton
Native title, agreement negotiations and
rent-seeking
The two concepts of financial compensation for
impacts and 'rent-seeking' are often elided and the concepts used
inappropriately in Australia, such as when it is applied to Aboriginal
proponents of negotiated financial benefits in mining agreements. It is
important then to understand the concept of 'rent-seeking' as it is most
often used in development economics. In this paper, we discuss the
revelevant literature, some misconceptions and the social aspects of
behaviour that have been labelled as 'rent-seeking' in the context of
the debate about the status of financial compensation to native title
groups from agreements with resource extraction companies.
Professor Marcia Langton is the Inaugural
Chair of Australian Indigenous Studies at the University of Melbourne.
She is also a Chief Investigator with the research project on
Agreements, Treaties and Negotiated Settlements.
Steve Larkin
Steve Larkin a Kungarakany
man from Darwin, Steve Larkin has been the Principal of AIATSIS since
June 2004. Prior to this, Mr Larkin acted as Principal for nine months
and was Deputy Principal for two and a half years. Mr Larkin has also
been Adjunct Associate Professor in Indigenous Health at James Cook
University since 2002, and maintains both an ongoing personal and
professional interest/involvement in Indigenous Australian health. He
spent more than 17 years working in health and community development
programs in urban, rural and remote Aboriginal communities throughout
the NT. Mr Larkin’s previous positions include National Aboriginal
Health Adviser to the Australian Medical Association, inaugural CEO of
the Secretariat of the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health
Organisation (NACCHO), Assistant Secretary in the Commonwealth Office of
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health (OATSIH), and a short stint
managing the national Indigenous Employment Program within the
Department of Employment, Workplace Relations and Small Business.
Craig Lubich
Introduction to investment for native title
groups
Successful claimants still have a number of
difficult financial issues to resolve. Not least of these is how to
effectively invest the capital for the long term benefit of the
traditional land owners and their descendants. There are myriad
investment alternatives with a confusing and conflicting range of
philosophies, implementation techniques and risks! How do you choose
the right one?
Successful investing means not only capturing risks
that generate expected return but reducing risks that do not. Avoidable
risks include holding too few securities, betting on companies or
industries, following market predictions, and speculating on
“information” from rating services. To all these, diversification is
the antidote. It washes away the random fortunes of individual stocks
and positions in an investor’s portfolio to capture returns of broad
economic forces.
Traditional managers do one of two things: Active
managers focus on picking individual stocks, the antithesis of
diversification; index managers hold many securities but mimic arbitrary
benchmarks.
Plan B chooses a different path. It structures
strategies based on scientific evidence rather than on commercial
indices. Our portfolios diversify not only in the amount of securities
they hold (thousands) but in the range of capital market strategies
developed. Small cap strategies target smaller stocks more
consistently. Value strategies target value returns with greater focus.
As a result investors achieve more consistent portfolio structure and
returns are achieved with lower risk.
Craig Lubich
is a director and co-founder of Plan B Financial Services Ltd. A
Certified Financial Planner™ and the most senior member of the Plan B
Adviser Team, Craig is responsible for the overall design and
development of the Corporate and Private Client Advisory Services
currently offered by Plan B. Driven by a passion for helping others
achieve their objectives and with almost twenty years experience in the
financial services industry, Craig's areas of expertise include
financial strategy analysis and portfolio implementation.
Bonita Mabo
Bonita Mabo and her husband, the late Eddie
(Koiki) Mabo, battled on behalf of Torres Strait Islanders for the
recognition of their native title. Since the 1960s Bonita has worked in
Indigenous organisations and at Townsville's Black Community School
while raising ten children. As a descendant of the Stolen Generation,
many of Bonita's battles have been highly personal and she continues to
campaign for the recognition the rights of her own people - the South
Sea Islanders.
Jim McNamara, Alfred Lacey Mayor, Ian Kuch, Kym Elston and Warren
Mundine
99 year leases on Aboriginal Land – not
the Northern Territory model
Jim McNamara is the Executive Director,
Indigenous Services, Queensland Department of Natural Resources and
Water, a position he has held for about 8 years. His office is
responsible for Queensland government Indigenous land access policy;
the management of native title claims on behalf of the State; the whole
of government processes for compliance with the Native Title Act; the
progress of land transfers under State land rights legislation; the
State framework for improved access to land and participation in natural
resource management; and, the implementation of the State cultural
heritage regime. Jim has worked in policy and legal areas of the
Queensland government concerning Indigenous land issues since 1993. In
1999 he worked for the Ministry of Justice, British Columbia on Treaty
negotiations.
Alf Lacey
is an Ewaiman traditional owner from
the Georgetown Country in North Queensland on his grandmother’s side and
Gaarrwa on his grandfathers side Western Queensland near Doomadgee
Northern Territory border.Alf done his schooling on Palm and then went
to boarding school on the mainland. Alf’s first job was on Palm,
entered the workforce while seventeen years of age. Most of his
working life has been on Palm and on the mainland, Alf worked for the
Department of Aboriginal Affairs as a Settlement worker; he also worked
at the Bwgcolman Community School.
Alf enjoys his life
on Palm, one of the most important things in Alf’s life, he spent
sometime in Darwin during the early 90’s this saw him travel the world
to such places as Canada to meet with the Cree Indians and a lot of
Indian Tribes from that area. Alf spent sometime in the Philippines
talking about Indigenous issues that affect all Aboriginal people at
home. Alf also did a stint at Geneva the UN Special Sitting on
Indigenous Peoples, which gave Alf a broader understanding on issues
that effect Aboriginal people across the world.
From that, Alf had
returned to Palm Island in 1993 and was elected as the ATSIC Regional
Council member for the Townsville Regional Council which included Palm.
Alf served a Consecutive three terms until ATSIC was abolished. Whilst
on ATSIC Alf managed to rub shoulders with some of the best Black
Politicians in the Country. Also in 1994, Alf was also elected as the
Mayor of Palm Island and served the full term, after that term Alf was
reelected as the Deputy Mayor of the Council and just recently Alf ran a
team in the 2008 Local Government Election which was called Palm United,
the results of those elections saw the majority of his team elected.
This exercise was not done on Palm before, so his team has created
history in Palm Local Politics.
The other things
Alf enjoys is quality family times, a very community orientated person
have been involved in local organisations such as, currently President
of the Palm Island Men’s Business Group, Board Member Ferdy’s Haven,
Catholic Diocese Aboriginal Advisory Council Member, elected Mayor Palm
Island Aboriginal Shire Council other things Alf enjoys reading,
fishing, watching sports from time to time, talking with other
communities about their Community issues, traditional dancing Alf gets
involved.
In closing Alf
believes the Political environment from Aboriginal Affairs at the moment
is probably one of the most interesting times in the life of a lot of
Aboriginal communities Nationally, we hope that while there are moves
for change to better our current status, that we don’t lose our Identity
with all this change.
Ian Kuch
has had over 20 years experience
working in Aboriginal communities in North Queensland from the Gulf to
the Cape and to the Yarrabah Community near Cairns. He has a solid
track record of success in achieving goals on a broad range of policy
areas affecting Aboriginal people.
Ian has been CEO of a number of successful
aboriginal business organisations as well as a former CEO of the North
Queensland Land Council. Since Leaving the North Queensland Land
Council in 2005, Ian has been employed as Governance Change Manager for
the Yarrabah Aboriginal Shire Council. Ian has recently been appointed
‘Transition Manager’ at the NQLC to oversee the realignment of the
NQLC’s boundary to include the current Central Queensland Land Council
Region.
Kym Elston is
deputy Principal Legal Officer of the NQLC.
Warren Mundine
is the Chief Executive Officer of NTSCORP Ltd., and an advocate for
lifting Indigenous people out of poverty and building a strong
Indigenous economy.
Warren is also a member
of the Australian Institute of Management, the Australian Institute of
Company Directors, the Chair of NSW Labor’s Indigenous Policy Committee,
a member of IAG’s Expert Community Advisors Committee, Executive Member
of the National Native Title Council, Executive member of the St.
Joseph’s College Indigenous Fund, Southern Cross University Foundation
and a Board member of NAISDA.
Warren is the former
National President of Australian Labor Party, Deputy Mayor of Dubbo and
former Chair of NSW Country Labor. He also is and had previously served
on the NSW PCYC State Board, as President of the NSW Local Government
Aboriginal Network, as an Executive member of the Local Government
Association of NSW, as a commissioner with the NSW Local Government
Grants Commission and a former member of the NSW Attorney General’s
Juvenile Crime Prevention Committee.
Kent McNeil
Recent developments in the Canadian law of Aboriginal title
In November, 2007, Justice
Vickers of the British Columbia Supreme Court delivered his judgment in
Tsilhqot’in Nation v. British Columbia. This is the most
significant Indigenous land rights case to be decided in Canada since
the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in Delgamuukw v.
British Columbia in 1997. In a 450-page judgment, Justice Vickers
dealt with proof and content of Aboriginal title and other Aboriginal
rights, extinguishment, infringement, third party interests,
reconciliation, and other matters.
In this presentation, I will
start by giving an overview of the Tsilhqot’in Nation decision.
I will then focus on the issue of reconciliation, in particular where
third party interests are involved. Included in this will be a
discussion of compensation and other remedies for the wrongful taking of
Aboriginal title lands. The relevance of the UN Declaration on the
Rights of Indigenous Peoples will also be discussed in relation to these
matters. I hope to provide an international perspective on these
matters that will be of assistance to Indigenous peoples who confront
equivalent issues in Australia.
Kent McNeil
is a professor at Osgoode Hall Law School in Toronto, Canada, where he
has taught since 1987. He is the author of numerous works on the rights
of Indigenous peoples, including two books: Common Law Aboriginal
Title (1989) and Emerging Justice? Essays on Indigenous Rights in
Canada and Australia
(2001). He has advised Indigenous groups in Canada on a variety of
issues, including land rights, self-government, and constitutional
matters.
Albert Mosby, Dimas Toby, Herbert Warusam, Pastor Jack Billy and
Cyril Manas
Native title in the Torres Strait - managing and dealing with the
issues
Albert Mosby is the Deputy Chairperson of
the Masigalgal (TSI) Corporation, which is the PBC for
Masig (Yorke), Umaga (Keats), Igaba
(Marsden), Mauar (Rennel) and Bak (Bourke) Islands, Damuth (Dalrymple)
Island native title area of the Torres Strait.
Dimas Toby is the Public Officer of Malu
Kiai (TSI) Corporation, which is the PBC for
Boigu, Moimi, Aubussi and surrounding
Islands native title area of the Torres
Strait.
Herbert Warusam is the Chairperson of
the Saibai Mura Buway (TSI) Corporation, which is the PBC for the
Saibai, Mawalmay Thoera, Thawpay Kawamag and
Kuykuthal Kawamag Islands native
title area of the Torres Strait.
Pastor Jack Billy is the Chairperson
of the Porumalgal (TSI) Corporation, which is the PBC for Poruma
(Coconut Island), in Torres Strait.
Cyril Manas is the Chairperson of the
Mualgal (TSI) Corporation, which is the PBC for Moa Island, in the
Torres Strait.
Michael Neal
Native Title and National Parks – Queensland style
Djabugay was the first
determination of native title over a national park in Queensland, in
2004. It did not include an agreement for joint management, despite:
- many years of negotiations, and
- proposals from Djabugay to apply the principles in Queensland’s
Nature Conservation Act.
Since the Djabugay
determination, progress towards joint management of national parks in
Queensland has slowly been made.
The presentation will
complement the Djabugay presentation, and briefly discuss:
- relevant principles of Queensland’s Nature Conservation Act,
- aspects of the Djabugay native title determination,
- recent developments in Queensland including the Cape York
Peninsula Heritage Act 2007, and
- standards of joint management reached in other areas of Australia,
and (yet again) ask why Queensland is so different to the rest of the
country.
Michael Neal is a partner of P & E Law,
which specialises in planning, environment and native title law. Michael
worked at the NLC and in the Northern Territory for 10 years from 1985,
including on Kakadu, Nitmiluk and Gurig national park joint management
issues, and in many mining negotiations. He then set up the legal
section of CYLC, and was the lawyer for the claimants in most of the
land claims over Queensland national parks. Among other recent work,
Michael represented Djabugay People in their native title determination
over the Barron Gorge National Park, and was the lawyer for the
traditional owners in the Argyle Diamond Mine ILUA.
Graeme Neate
Achieving real outcomes from native title claims: meeting the
challenges head on
The President of the National Native Title
Tribunal, Graeme Neate, will provide a frank analysis of the current
state of the native title system and offer some options for the future.
Most of the native title claims that have been finalised so far have
been relatively straightforward to resolve. Now that those claims are
complete, parties face the challenge of finding ways to progress the
remaining, more complex claims so that at least some applicants see
results in their lifetime. Graeme Neate will explore a number of ways to
move forward, including looking outside usual practice and developing
innovative alternatives to settling native title issues. This could
include more creative and corporative approaches between the levels of
government, and other parties and marrying what claimants want to
achieve with the best fit settlement options.
Graeme Neate
has been President of the National Native Title Tribunal since 1999. Mr
Neate was a part-time member of the Tribunal from 1995 before becoming
President.
Before joining the Tribunal, Mr Neate was
the Chairperson of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Lands
Tribunal in Queensland and a member of the Land Court of Queensland.
From 1988 to 1991, he was a senior solicitor in commercial property and
environmental law at Freehill Hollingdale and Page, Sydney, and from
1986 to 1988 was the Principal Legal Officer with the Constitutional
Commission. Mr Neate worked with the Department of Aboriginal Affairs in
Canberra from 1982 to 1986 on a range of Aboriginal heritage and land
matters. He became Director of the Legal Advising Section and assisted
Justice Toohey with a comprehensive review of the Aboriginal Land
Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cwlth). Mr Neate also chaired
a panel of lawyers assisting the Federal Minister for Aboriginal Affairs
and the Aboriginal Steering Committee with proposals for the
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 (Cwlth).
Mr Neate has a Bachelor of Arts and Bachelor of Laws (with Honours) from
the Australian National University in Canberra. He is admitted to
practise as a legal practitioner in the Australian Capital Territory and
Northern Territory, and as a solicitor in New South Wales and
Queensland. He is also on the roll of barristers and solicitors in the
High Court. Mr Neate has published a book and numerous articles,
chapters and conference papers on indigenous land and cultural heritage
matters.
Dan O’Dea
Land Access and Native Title
The object of the Native Title Act is to provide for the recognition and
protection of native title and to establish ways in which future
dealings affecting native title may proceed and set standards for those
dealings.
National Native Title Tribunal member Dan O’Dea
will discuss ways to reach the objective within the Right to Negotiate
provisions of the Native Title Act, and particularly good faith.
Dan O'Dea
has been a full-time member of the National Native Title Tribunal since
December 2002. Prior to his appointment to the Tribunal,
Mr O'Dea was the Principal Legal Officer of the native title unit in the
Ngaanyatjarra Council since 1996. At the Council he represented
Indigenous people of the Central Desert in native title applications and
negotiations. Before 1995 he worked as a commercial litigator in Western
Australia. In 2007 Mr O'Dea was reappointed for a further five years.
Slim Parker, Bill Hart and Janina Gawler
The Marnda Mia CNC Pty Ltd: Building Aboriginal Prosperity and
Regional Capacity in the Pilbara
This paper explores the establishment of a regional
body for Traditional Owner interests in the Pilbara, the Marnda Mia CNC
Pty Ltd. Auspiced initially by the Pilbara’s regional native title
representative body (PNTS), Marnda Mia Central Negotiating Committee
formed a partnership with Rio Tinto Iron Ore to build intergenerational
prosperity for Aboriginal people of the Pilbara. Traditional Owners of
the Pilbara requested Rio Tinto Iron Ore’s assistance in establishing an
independent company which could build prosperity and allow them to
maintain their traditions for future generations. Following extensive
consultations, Marnda Mia CNC Pty Ltd was established in 2007 to
represent the regional interests of Pilbara Traditional Owners impacted
by Rio Tinto Iron Ore’s operations. This new institution is directly
assisting in negotiating a regional framework agreement with PNTS and
Rio Tinto Iron Ore on education and training, employment, business
development, cultural heritage and environmental land management
standards. More than just a mechanism for implementing the regional
framework agreement between Rio Tinto Iron Ore and Traditional Owners,
Marnda Mia CNC is a registered independent company through which
Traditional Owner groups can pool their knowledge and experience,
leverage their ability to develop regional partnerships with companies
and government, and engage in commercial enterprise. It also provides
industry and government with a mechanism for dealing transparently and
openly with all Traditional Owner groups across the region, rather than
adopt a protracted, piecemeal approach to engagement.
Slim Parker is the Chairperson of the Marnda
Mia CNC Pty Ltd and a Traditional Owner of the Martu Idja Banyjima
(MIB). He is a well regarded leader and Elder in the region and has been
chairperson of Karijini Corporation for many years. Slim has been a long
term activist in the Pilbara region seeking to ensure recognition and
respect for his people. He has been at the forefront of challenging
mining companies since the Marandoo mine in the Pilbara in the early
1990s.
Bill Hart is General Manager Communities at
Rio Tinto Iron Ore. Bill has been involved in managing the agreements
with the Traditional Owners of the Pilbara since 2006. He has been with
the Rio Tinto Group since 2000 and has a long association with the
resource industry.
Janina Gawler is the Principal Consultant at
Cooperative Change, a company which specialises in facilitating regional
development and Aboriginal partnerships. Janina has a long history of
working with Aboriginal people and has established a consultancy which
works with corporations, government and Indigenous communities to build
long term relationships and ensure improved outcomes for Indigenous
people across Australia.
Margaret Raven
Native title, policy development and sustainability
Policy development by government agencies and
industry are often done in the absence of adequate consultation with
Indigenous peoples. These policies tend to be at odds with the visions
and aspirations of Indigenous peoples and Indigenous sustainability.
Native title, and the structures and processes it bore, was initially
conceived to allow legal recognition of ‘native title rights.’ However,
as increasing numbers of native title claims are resolved, Australia
will begin to enter a post-native title phase, and uncertainty over
Indigenous peoples’ connection to country will decline. In the current
absence of sound processes and structures for Indigenous consultation on
policy development and sustainability, the existing native title system
offers some opportunities for Indigenous peoples to gain access to
government and industry policy development. This paper explores the role
of the existing native title system in wider policy development and
sustainability agendas.
Margaret Raven
is Senior Policy Officer at Yamatji Marlpa Barna Baba Maaja Aboriginal
Corporation (YMBBMAC). Before joining YMBBMAC in early 2007, Margaret
worked full-time on a PhD with Murdoch University and Desert Knowledge
Cooperative Research Centre. Her research has focused on organisational
recognition of Indigenous rights to knowledge. Through her research she
has worked with the United Nations University-Institute of Advanced
Studies, and been involved in international negotiations through the
United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity, and the World
Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO). Margaret has worked for the
Department of Indigenous Affairs, and has a Bachelor of Science (Honors)
with a Major in Geography. She hopes to complete her PhD before the end
of the year.
Eric Ripper
The Hon Eric S Ripper is Deputy Premier;
Treasurer; Minister for State Development and carries responsibility for
native title. Eric Ripper has been Western Australia's Deputy Premier
and Treasurer since the State Labor Government was first elected in
February 2001. Eric is also Minister for State Development. The
Treasurer is responsible for delivering Western Australia's $19billion a
year State Budget; preserving the State's AAA credit rating; and
overseeing the Government's economic reform agenda. As State Development
Minister, Eric has responsibility for facilitating and coordinating the
State's major resources projects. Eric is also responsible, with his
native title portfolio, for delivering recognition of traditional rights
to Western Australia's Indigenous people. He was elected to the Western
Australian State Parliament in 1988 and previous Ministerial portfolios
have included: Minister for Government Enterprises; Minister for Energy;
Minister for Community Services; and Minister for Disability Services.
Born in 1951, Eric was raised on a wheat and sheep farm at Nyabing in
the Great Southern and educated at Nyabing Primary School, Churchlands
Senior High School and the University of Western Australia, graduating
with a Bachelor of Arts and a Diploma of Education. Eric lives in his
electorate of Belmont and has two adult children.
Paul Rosair and David Collard
Department of Water –Indigenous Engagement and Capacity Building in
water resource management.
The Department of Water have initiated several
projects that provides a useful case study on the Indigenous Engagement
and Capacity Building in water resource management and the department’s
response to Native Title determinations. The learning’s from these
experiences will be presented in terms of the past and present with some
perspectives on the future.
The Department of Water established the Indigenous
Support Unit in 2005 and started to develop new initiatives to assist
the department to engage the Indigenous community across the state. The
ISU also provided advice in how the department could assist with
capacity building and several new projects started to flow from this
two-fold approach.
Under engagement the department started to train
all of it’s staff in Aboriginal cross cultural awareness training,
almost 70% of a 600 FTE organisation have completed the training. The
department also commenced consultation with Native Title Working Groups
under the South West Aboriginal land and Sea Council in water planning.
Several workshops were conducted with the NT Working Groups to identify
and discuss the issues of the Indigenous community in the south-west
region of Western Australia. This process allowed the NT Traditional
Owners to have an input into the department’s regional plan for the
south west region.
The department is also responding to certain
determination’s and is trying to engage the NT Traditional Owners in
managing the vast number of water reserves vested in the department
across the state. The development of a Management Plan for a reserve
located near Lake Argyle has seen the establishment of a Joint
Management Committee between the Miriuwung Gajerrong people near
Kununurra.
Paul Rosair is the Director of Water
Resource Business Operations in charge of regional operations in the
Department of Water. Paul graduated in Business Computing from Curtin
University with additional qualifications in hydrography and has more
than thirty years experience in the water industry, primarily on water
resource management.
David Collard is the Indigenous Affairs
Coordinator employed in the Indigenous Support Unit attached to the
Business Operations division. David graduated in Social Sciences from
the Curtin University of WA and has more than twenty years experience in
the Indigenous Affairs arena.
Rocky Sainty and Melissa George
National caring for country strategy: Black hands on the steering
wheel
Rocky Sainty is an Indigenous Land
Management Facilitator for Tasmania, ATSIC Regional councillor, and
previously Chair of Tasman.
Melissa George has a background in
Archaeology and Protected Area Management studying part time for five
years at James Cook University and the University of Queensland. She
has been actively involved in the protection and management of land and
sea through community natural resource management projects and liaising
with and advising State and Commonwealth government. She is actively
involved with cultural heritage surveys, property planning and on ground
NRM activities including weed management and revegetation.
Don Sanders
Indigenous Australians in the upstream oil and gas industry
The oil and gas industry is finding the urgent need
for skilled personnel in its operations both onshore and
offshore. Wherever possible the industry is partnering with communities
to provide a training and employment opportunity for Indigenous
Australians. The industry has also found the shift from conventional
native title negotiations to arrangements where indigenous training and
employment are becoming common in native title agreements. Such
arrangements can provide longer-term of certainty for indigenous
communities through both direct and indirect employment.
At the end of 2007, the
Australian Petroleum Production and Exploration Association (APPEA)and
its member companies received Australian Government support, through the
National Skills Shortages Strategy (NSSS), for a range of practical
initiatives designed to increase VET participation and to particularly
broaden employment opportunities for groups currently under-represented
in the oil and gas sector, including:
- the development of specific pilot programs for Indigenous
Australians to increase entry opportunities into the oil and gas
industry in Western Australia, South Australia and the Northern
Territory, and
- ensuring that preparatory programs targeting adult Indigenous
Australians in the Pilbara and Kimberley regions of Western Australia
are in place.
Don Sanders, returned to
WA in 1983 as a career advisor operating in secondary schools, district
and central office, after working in the UK between 1969 and 1982 in a
range of industry settings. Don.
won a twelve month secondment to
Woodside in 1994 to evaluate the Northwest Shelf Project’s curriculum
materials, and to integrate the petroleum industry awareness Schools
Information Program (SIP) into the school curriculum. Following a
further stint with the WA Education Department, he accepted the position
as national education manager with the Australian Petroleum Production
and Exploration Association (APPEA) where he was responsible for
directing industry awareness programs and providing curriculum support
materials in all states and territories. Don is currently the APPEA
Director for the NT, People and Security. He has a Master of Education
(Career Education) and is a life member of both the Petroleum Club of WA
and the WA Career Education Association. He is also a member of PESA,
SPE and AIE.
Tom Smith
Community natural resource and cultural heritage management planning
This presentation will inform of the new Australian
Government Caring for our Country natural resource management program by
the Department of Environment, Water, Heritage and Arts. The program has
six priority areas: national reserve system;
biodiversity and natural icons; coastal environments and critical
aquatic habitats; sustainable farm practices; natural resource
management in remote and northern Australia; and community skills,
knowledge and engagement. The program includes funds to implement
election commitments to: rescue the Great Barrier Reef; repair our
fragile coastal ecosystems; save the endangered Tasmanian Devil; improve
water quality in the Gippsland Lakes; fight the Cane Toad menace;
employ additional Indigenous
Rangers; expand the Indigenous Protected Area network; and assist
Indigenous Australians enter the carbon trading market. A strategic
approach to supporting Indigenous communities to access these programs
is for Communities to develop their community Natural Resource and
Cultural Heritage Management Plans The presentation will cover a guide
to getting support to develop the plan, a framework to consider issues
which need to be covered in the plan and implementation of the completed
plan.
The development of the plans will
involve community participation, community ownership. The plans will
provide agreed direction for community and establish partnerships with
other essential stakeholders. The implementation of the Plans will take
strong Leadership and commitment to make it reality to achieve desired
aspirations. Today, funding proposals require evidence of such natural
resource and cultural heritage management plans to show community
support , how the particular project fits to wider community
aspirations, and appropriate governance for the project.
Tom Smith
comes from Cowra in the Wiradjuri Tribal area of NSW. Tom is the
Coordinator of a national project-“Indigenous participation in natural
resource management” within the Commonwealth Department of
Environment,Water,Heritage and Arts (4years). He was previously employed
as Manager of the Aboriginal Land Rights Unit within the NSW Aboriginal
Land Council (6 years). Tom also has a Diploma of Teaching and a
Bachelor of Education Degree.
Roy Stone, Johnny Hopiga and Dean Mathews
La Grange groundwater – native title and Indigenous engagement in
water planning.
The La Grange groundwater allocation planning
process provides a useful case study on native title and Indigenous
engagement in water resource planning. The La Grange groundwater area,
south of Broome, was the subject of a large scale irrigation proposal in
1998 to grow cotton. There was considerable local opposition to the
proposal, particularly from Traditional Owners. A water allocation
planning process was initiated by the Department of Water to engage with
the key stakeholders as part of its assessment of the irrigation
proposal. Most of the groundwater area was covered by the Karajarri
native title claim and the cotton growing proposal as well as the water
planning became inextricably linked with the native title determination
process. The presentation will outline the nature of the indigenous
engagement in water planning. This will cover the specific consultation
arrangements and the investigation work to identify the indigenous
cultural values in conjunction with the environmental values of
groundwater dependant features. The influence of the native title
determination process on the cotton proposal and the water planning will
be outlined.
The present situation with regard to finalisation
of the La Grange groundwater management plan will be outlined. The
Karajarri native title consent determination in relation to native title
rights to water will be discussed. Based on these learnings from the
past and present, future perspectives on indigenous access to water and
engagement in water management will be discussed.
Johnny Hopiga is a Karajarri man and Head
Ranger of the Karajarri Rangers. He has an outstation on country and
teaches kids Karajarri law. Johnny is also a committee member of the
Karajarri Traditional Lands Association.
Dean Mathews is an Indigenous Natural
Resource Management Officer in the Kimberley Region of the Department of
Water. Dean was responsible for the development of an indigenous
translation DVD on water allocation planning and licencing in the La
Grange groundwater area.
Roy Stone is the Program Manager in charge
of regional water planning in the Department of Water. Roy graduated in
Civil Engineering from the University of WA and has more than thirty
years experience in the water industry, primarily on water resource
planning.
Lisa Strelein
The Year in Review
The Year in Review is an
annual feature of the Native Title Conference. In a year dominated by
the outcomes of a series of important full Federal Court decisions, some
of the significant outcomes achieved on the ground may have gone
unnoticed. This presentation provides an opportunity to reflect on the
achievements over the last twelve months, the key determinations and
agreements reached.
Dr Lisa Strelein is the Director of the
Research programs at AIATSIS. Lisa’s research and publications have
focused on the relationship between Indigenous peoples and the state,
and the role of the courts in defining Indigenous peoples’ rights. Lisa
has made a significant contribution to academic debate on native title
in Australia, including her recent book Compromised Jurisprudence:
Native Title Cases since Mabo, which was heralded by members of the
judiciary and Indigenous community alike. She also writes for a wide
variety of audiences and has worked with teams in creating a catalogue
for a native title art exhibition and an award winning multi-media
package on native title. Lisa maintains strong networks within the
native title system, conducting research projects in partnership with or
in response to the needs of native title representative bodies and
claimants as well as government departments. Lisa is the convenor of
the annual National Native Title Conference, which remains the leading
annual Indigenous policy conference in Australia. Lisa has degrees in
Commerce and Law and was awarded a PhD, for her thesis examining
Indigenous sovereignty and the common law, from the ANU Research School
of Social Sciences in 1998.
Austin Sweeney
Practical and strategic considerations in setting up and running an
effective PBC
There are many challenges facing native title
holders and NTRBs in setting up and running an effective PBC. This
paper looks at some of those challenges from the perspective of both the
NTRB/NTSP, and the PBC and the native title holders it represents.
Native title holders and their NTRB/NTSP need to consider a number of
strategic and practical issues as well as matters of detail when setting
up a PBC. There are also significant challenges to be addressed in the
early years of a PBC's operation if it is to realise the aspirations of
native title holders. For most new and existing PBCs there is the
ongoing challenge of becoming and remaining effective in carrying out
their functions in a difficult environment of limited capacity, funding
and resources. There is also the challenge of making the transition to
operate under the Corporations (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander)
Act and amendments to the Native Title Act and the Native Title (PBC)
Regulations. This paper looks at some practical ways in which these
various challenges might be addressed by PBCs and NTRBs/NTSPs.
Austin Sweeney is a lawyer and mediator who
has practised in the area of land rights and native title for over 15
years. As a legal officer for the Central Land Council he worked on a
number of land rights and native title claims in the Northern
Territory. In more recent years Austin has been working with native
title holders to develop their capacity to manage their PBCs, resolve
disputes, and negotiate native title agreements. He is currently working
with native title holders and related organisations around the country
on these issues.
Fred Tanner
Indigenous access to water and the National Water Initiative
Governments across Australia are in the early stages
of formally recognising Aboriginal relationships with water for
spiritual, cultural and economic purposes. In the recent past government
action has primarily focussed on informal partnerships with Aboriginal
groups to gain Aboriginal perspectives on water governance arrangements.
Often this has included targeted consultation with peak Aboriginal
bodies. There is a growing awareness that current water governance
arrangements in Australia are not providing sufficient access to water
to meet Aboriginal people’s spiritual, cultural and economic
requirements. This is reflected in the National Water Initiative
Inter-governmental Agreement (NWI). The NWI Agreement demonstrates a
commitment by all states and territories to ‘[include] indigenous
representation in water planning’, ‘incorporate indigenous social,
spiritual and customary objectives and strategies’ and ‘take account of
the possible existence of native title rights to water’. This has
provided impetus for states and territories to reassess the way in
which, through policy, legislation and programs, they provide for
Aboriginal access to water. This paper summarises findings on a scoping
study of policy and legislation, undertaken to assess Aboriginal access
to water, International case studies have also been investigated.
Fred Tanner is of Arabunna descent and was
born in Port Augusta in South Australia. In early 1986, he moved to
Adelaide to study fulltime, completing an Associate Diploma in Community
Administration and a bachelor degrees in Arts and Law. Fred practiced as
criminal lawyer with the Legal Aid Commission of South Australia before
moving to the Aboriginal Legal Rights Movements Native Title Unit to
practice native title and Aboriginal heritage law until 2002. Since then
he has worked in the South Australian Public Service in a variety of
policy roles. During this period Fred has been a member on the Law
Society of SA’s Aboriginal Issues and Human Rights committees and Law
Council of Australian Indigenous Advisory Committee. In 2003, the
Minister responsible to the Arid Areas Water Management Catchment Board
and the subsequent South Australian Arid Lands Natural Resources
Management Board appointed Fred as a member. He has also served as a
member of the State-wide Aboriginal Advisory Committee to the South
Australian Natural Resources Council. His current
role with the Department of Water, Land and Biodiversity Conservation
involves the National Water Initiative, particularly the implementation
of the paragraphs 52 to 54 – Indigenous Access.
Jessica Weir
Native title and water: political/legal transformations in their
ecological context
Recent water laws and policies have separated water
from land, and water has been privatised so it can be traded in water
markets. As new forms of water property are identified, different lobby
groups make rights arguments to gain water entitlements. Everybody has
rights hanging in the balance at water negotiation tables, and
Indigenous peoples’ draw on their native title rights, and justice and
equity principles, to make arguments about their rights to water.
However, the destruction of fresh water ecologies makes rights arguments
between humans an irrelevancy. In this talk I describe how we need to
resituate these debates within their ecological relationships.
Dr Jessica Weir is a Visiting Research
Fellow in the Native Title Research Unit at AIATSIS. Jessica is a
geographer whose research focuses on ecological and social issues in
Australia, particularly water and ecological devastation. Jessica is a
member of the Ecological Humanities, a group of people who foster
research that traverses the great divides between the sciences and the
humanities, including theories, research and methodologies on the
artificial separation of nature/culture. Jessica has ten years
experience working in native title research, and has also worked in the
non-government sector with local communities on environment and
livelihood issues in Bangladesh and Thailand.
Murray Wilcox, Ron Merkel and Mick Dodson
Judicial reflections on the state of native title law
This expert panel will be asked to share their
views on the current state of native title law.
Murray Wilcox served
as a judge of the Federal Court of Australia, since 1984. He also served
as a Judge of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory and
the Supreme Court of Norfolk Island. Wilcox was also Chief Justice of
the Industrial Relations Court of Australia.
Wilcox was the Acting
Chairman of the Australian Law Reform Commission 1984-85, and served as
Commissioner between 1984-89 and 1976-79. He was the Foundation
President of the Environmental Law Association NSW (1981) and President
of the Australian Conservation Foundation from 1979-84. From 1974-76 his
Honour was a Member of the Australian Advisory Committee on the
Environment.
Wilcox retired from the Federal Court in October
2006. His final decision was the interim judgment in the Single Noongar
case. Wilcox presided over many other historic cases including the
dispute between the Maritime Union of Australia and Patrick Stevedores.
Ron Merkel has returned to practice at the
Victorian Bar after ten years as a Judge at the Federal Court of
Australia. He intends to primarily focus on public interest and
indigenous matters, but will also be available to act in complex matters
either as counsel, mediator or arbitrator. Merkel was admitted to
practice in 1964 and has since been admitted in several Australian
jurisdictions and in the Pacific.
Professor Mick Dodson
is the Chairperson of AIATSIS and is a prominent
advocate on issues affecting Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait
Islander peoples as well as other Indigenous peoples around the world.
He was Australia’s first Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social
Justice Commissioner with the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity
Commission. He is currently the Director of the National Centre for
Indigenous Studies at the Australian National University, the Special
Rapporteur for the United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues,
and a Director of Dodson, Bauman and Associates Pty Ltd, legal and
anthropological consultants. He holds a Bachelor of Jurisprudence and a
Bachelor of Laws from Monash University, an honorary Doctorate of
Letters from the University of Technology and an honorary Doctorate of
Laws from the University of New South Wales.
Ted Wilkes
Introductory remarks: reinvigorating transition zones for Noongar
youth
Associate Professor Wilkes is a Nyungar man
from Western Australia whose professional background includes working
for the Western Australia Museum, the Centre for Aboriginal Studies at
Curtin University of Technology, and sixteen years as the Director of
the Derbarl Yerrigan Health Service. He is currently employed in the
Indigenous Research Program at the National Drug Research Institute,
Curtin University of Technology. Professor Wilkes is a member of the
Australian National Council on Drugs and is the Chair of the National
Indigenous Drug and Alcohol Council and he provides advice and expertise
to various other state, national and international committees. As an
Aboriginal leader, Professor Wilkes has endeavoured to facilitate
positive health and social outcomes, for the Aboriginal community, as
well as the community generally.
Joe Williams
The Mabo Lecture
Chief Judge Williams was appointed Chief
Judge, Mäori Land Court in December 1999. He is also the Chairperson of
the Waitangi Tribunal. He completed an LLB at Victoria University in
Wellington in 1985. He was a junior lecturer in law at Victoria
University in Wellington from 1986-1987, before gaining a Masters degree
with first class honours in indigenous rights law at the University of
British Columbia in Vancouver in 1988. He returned to New Zealand and
in 1994, he co-founded Walters Williams and Co. He specialised in
litigation in areas of resource management and environmental law, Mäori
issues and Treaty of Waitangi claims, Mäori land law, all areas of
administrative and public law. In 1999 he was awarded the Mäori
Students Millennium Prize as a former student of Victoria University of
Wellington. In 2001 he was appointed Fellow of Victoria University of
Wellington Law Faculty.
Phillip Williams
Native title charitable trust funds
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people
throughout Australia are receiving compensation as their rights to land
are being recognised. For many groups finding the most effective way to
manage the communities assets can be a great challenge. One way of
managing these assets is to establish a charitable trust, this is a
particularly good model if the group intends to address things such as
health, education and the promotion and protection of their culture.
Plan B Trustees limited has been managing a number of charitable trusts
on behalf of multiple claimat groups since 2001. It is this experience
that has led our organisation to be in the position it is today. The
presentation will include an overview of the manner in which our company
has evolved in relation to managing charitable trusts and the latest
development in this evolutionary process.
Phillip Williams is the Head of Native Title
Trusts with Plan B Trustees Limited. Phillip specialises in
administering trust funds for the management of compensation payments
resulting from native title claims. Phillip has a Certificate in Small
Business Management, Diploma of Business Management, Graduate
Certificate in Indigenous Studies form Curtin University and is
currently undertaking a Bachelor of Commerce. He has also completed an
Introductory Proficiency Certificate from the Executor and Trustee
Institute. Phillip has worked with the law firm Freehill Holingdale and
Page followed by two years with the Australian Securities and
Investments Commission. In 2000 he commenced work with Plan B Trustees
Limited where he is currently.
David Worth
The impact of ‘peak oil’ on Indigenous economic development
aspirations
Nearly all of the debate about rising petrol prices
in Australia has been focused on the effects on the large proportion of
Australians that live in urban areas. However, there has already been a
serious impact on the many Indigenous Australians living in remote
communities due to higher fuel prices. Nearly all of these small
communities in WA, and throughout Central and Northern Australia, use
diesel fuel for their power supply, as well as for transport.
Electricity generated by diesel fuel is almost universal in these
communities.
For many communities, electric power is the key
component to their sustainability as they manage their native title
rights and try to maintain their culture on their traditional lands.
Additionally, many of these communities have developed future economic
plans based around cheap fuels, eg tourism. This paper analyses the
future challenges of building viable and sustainable communities in
remote Australia in the face of even higher future world oil prices due
to ‘peak oil’.
Dr David Worth completed his PhD in
sociology at Murdoch University, Western Australia, and is presently
employed in the Research Unit at the National Native Title Tribunal. His
first degree was in aeronautical engineering and he has also completed a
MBA. For the past 25 years he has worked in a voluntary capacity in
various roles for many social change organisations in both Western
Australia and the eastern States. He has undertaken detailed research
over the past 5 years into the decline in world oil production and its
impact on Indigenous communities in Australia and Canada.
David Yarrow
Does native title compensation have a future? Comparing Australian
and international Indigenous rights and title compensation
The law of native title compensation is everywhere and nowhere.
Negotiated agreements, including indigenous land use agreements, almost
invariably deal with compensation in one form or another. Consent
determinations are often underpinned by agreements that limit or waive
the compensation liability. But no one has a firm grip on the actual
quantum of compensation involved in these transactions. This lack of
understanding, on all sides of native title litigation, has 3 causes:
- uncertainty about what acts are compensable, particularly when
done prior to the recognition of native title in Mabo [No2];
- uncertainty about the methodology for quantifying compensation for
acts that are compensable;
- uncertainty about the date at which the obligation to pay
compensation crystallizes, with difficulties that flow from that
including uncertain validity and uncertain quantum.
This paper will consider the law of Canada and the United States, and
how those jurisdictions have responded to the problem of valuing the
compensable impairment or extinguishment of Indigenous rights and title.
It will also describe how most existing valuation methodologies, based
as they are on the compulsory purchase model of the Land Clauses
Consolidation Act 1845 (UK), are inapt for direct application to the
valuation of native title compensation.
David Yarrow is a member of the Queensland Bar. Before moving
to the Bar, he was a lecturer at the Monash University Faculty of Law
where he taught property, equity and trusts law.
Indigenous
Talking Circles
Native title and the new government
Facilitator: Mick Dodson
This Indigenous Talking Circle will consider the new policy
environment for native title that may emerge under the new Labor
government. In particular, delegates will be invited to discuss the
Attorney General’s call for greater emphasis on reaching agreement and
reducing emphasis on connection reports, and to provide direction to all
governments on how the native title system could be improved.
Passing on knowledge: keeping law strong
Discussion leaders: Johnny Hopiga & Shirley Spratt
This Indigenous Talking Circle will focus on the transmission of law
and knowledge to young people as an integral part of sustaining the
systems of law that give rise to native title.
Distribution and management of benefits from native title
Facilitator: TBC
This Indigenous Talking circle will provide a unique opportunity for
Indigenous people from around the country to share ideas, problems and
solutions to the sometimes difficult decisions about the use, management
and distribution of benefits from native title agreements and
settlements.
National caring for country strategy: Black hands on the steering
wheel
Discussion leaders: Melissa George, Joe Morrison, Chrissy Grant &
Rocky Sainty
The Indigenous Advisory Committee (IAC) advises
the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and the Arts on the operation
of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (EPBC
Act) taking into account the significance of Indigenous people’s
knowledge. The IAC is now championing the development of a National
Caring for Country Strategy. The strategy’s purpose is to outline
Indigenous aspirations and interests in land and sea management,
including those that relate to broader health, economic development and
social issues. In this Indigenous talking circle IAC members would
like to engage delegates in a discussion about the proposed strategy -
including, what it could achieve, what it should contain, and how it
should be implemented.
Women’s perspectives on native title
(Indigenous women delegates only)
Facilitator: TBC
Discussion leaders: Lhere Artepe women
Following from the success of the Indigenous women’s talking circle
at last years conference, Indigenous women delegates will again meet
together to discuss their perspectives and roles in the native title
process and in the sustenance of culture and nurturing of Indigenous
identities.
Indigenous representation
Facilitator: Tom Calma
This Indigenous Talking Circle will consider the place of traditional
owners and native title holders in any Indigenous representative
arrangements. This discussion will allow commentary and feedback on the
Social Justice Commissioner’s address to the Conference.
Indigenous leadership
Facilitator: Geoffrey Richardson
This Indigenous Talking Circle will explore notions
of leadership, focusing the personal strength of men, women and youth
and the power to demonstrate leadership in every aspect of our lives.
Native title: big opportunities for small business
Facilitator:
This Indigenous talking Circle will provide an
opportunity to share ideas for small business development, drawing on
others who have experience in running businesses and develop a greater
understanding of some of the unique considerations needed to establish
and successfully manage a business in the native title context.
Workshops
NNTC Policy Table
Convenor: Carolyn Betts
A session at the end of each day has been set aside
for delegates to participate in a round table discussion of issues
raised by the conference and to plan for the future of native title for
Indigenous peoples. These sessions will focus on the formulation of
policy solutions to help guide a positive agenda for native title that
can be pursued by the National Native Title Council, and other
representative bodies with a national voice, as well as by native title
holders and claimants themselves.
Transitioning to the CATSI Act: a practical workshop to get you
transitioned to the new law
Convenor: Anthony Bevan
The Office of the Registrar of Indigenous Corporations (ORIC) will
present a workshop for Indigenous corporations. The workshop will
provide information on the requirements of the new Corporations
(Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander) Act 2006, which is generally
referred to as the CATSI ACT. All PBCs are registered under this
legislation. The workshop will help Indigenous corporations understand
what they are required to do in order to transfer to the CATSI Act. It
will describe how each Indigenous corporation can design its new Rule
Book to meet the requirements of this legislation. The workshop will
also be an opportunity for Indigenous corporations to inform ORIC
representatives of ways in which ORIC can effectively support them.
National Native Title Tribunal forum: Questions & Answers
Convenor: Tim Evans
The National Native Title Tribunal can provide assistance and
information to all people involved in the native title process. Knowing
it is available is one thing, but knowing how to get the assistance,
what type of assistance is most suitable and then how to use it
effectively is just as important. The Tribunal will conduct an open
session with some of its specialist teams including geospatial and
research to give an insight into what is available.
|